Isabel T Rubio
Research Interests
Make your next move.
Prepare your application
Review drafts before you send them.
Explore related searches
Articles (4)
PURPOSE We assessed the accuracy and reproducibility of Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer's (ChatGPT) recommendations in response to breast cancer patients by comparing generated outputs with consensus expert opinions. METHODS 362 consecutive breast cancer patients sourced from a weekly international breast cancer webinar series were submitted to a tumor board of renowned experts. The same 362 clinical patients were also prompted to ChatGPT-4.0 three separate times to examine reproducibility. RESULTS Only 46% of ChatGPT-generated content was entirely concordant with the recommendations of breast cancer experts, and only 39% of ChatGPT's responses demonstrated inter-response similarity. ChatGPT's responses demonstrated higher concordance with CEN experts in earlier stages of breast cancer (0, I, II, III) compared to advanced (IV) patients ( P = .019). There were less accurate responses from ChatGPT when responding to patients involving molecular markers and genetic testing ( P = .025), and in patients involving antibody drug conjugates ( P = .006). ChatGPT's responses were not necessarily incorrect but often omitted specific details about clinical management. When the same prompt was independently sent to CEN into the model on three occasions, each time by difference users, ChatGPT's responses exhibited variable content and formatting in 68% (246 out of 362) of patients and were entirely consistent with one another in only 32% of responses. CONCLUSION Since this promising clinical decision-making support tool is widely used currently by physicians worldwide, it is important for the user to understand its limitations as currently constructed when responding to multidisciplinary breast cancer patients, and for researchers in the field to continue improving its ability with contemporary, accurate and complete breast cancer information. As currently constructed, ChatGPT is not engineered to generate identical outputs to the same input and was less likely to correctly interpret and recommend treatments for complex breast cancer patients.
Year:
2025
Population-based screening programs aim to detect the disease at an early stage, so less treatment will be needed as well as having better oncological outcomes when diagnosed earlier. In the majority of European countries, breast cancer screening programs are designed based on women age. Meta-analysis of randomized clinical trial data demonstrates a reduction in the relative risk of breast cancer mortality due to screening, which has been estimated to be approximately 20%. One of the controversies about the population breast screening programs is that age-based screening ignores women’s individual breast cancer risk. Identification of high-risk women may intensify the screening measures and will optimize the population screening programs to align them to individual risks. Family history of breast cancer is one of the risk factors to consider along with the recently developed polygenic risk scores to stratify women into a risk group. Other factors to assess risk include: mammographic breast density; B3 lesions with atypia in breast biopsy specimens; hormonal and lyfestyle and, potentially, epigenetic markers. Still, there are some difficulties in validating these factors and reflecting the interaction between risk factors in the models. Ongoing screening trials (e.g., WISDOM and MyPebs) are currently evaluating the clinical acceptability and utility of risk-stratified screening programs in the general population, and should provide valuable information for the possible implementation of such programs. Communication of complex risk information to the women, as well as assessing ethical concerns need to be addressed before implementation of risk stratified programs.
Year:
2024
PURPOSE A number of studies are currently investigating de-escalation of radiation therapy in patients with a low risk of in-breast relapses on the basis of clinicopathologic factors and molecular tests. We evaluated whether 70-gene risk score is associated with risk of locoregional recurrence (LRR) and estimated 8-year cumulative incidences for LRR in patients with early-stage breast cancer treated with breast conservation. METHODS In this exploratory substudy of European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer 10041/BIG 03-04 MINDACT trial, we evaluated women with a known clinical and genomic 70-gene risk score test result and who had breast-conserving surgery (BCS). The primary end point was LRR at 8 years, estimated by cumulative incidences. Distant metastasis and death were considered competing risks. RESULTS Among 6,693 enrolled patients, 5,470 (81.7%) underwent BCS, of whom 98% received radiotherapy. At 8-year follow-up, 189 patients experienced a LRR, resulting in an 8-year cumulative incidence of 3.2% (95% CI, 2.7 to 3.7). In patients with a low-risk 70-gene signature, the 8-year LRR incidence was 2.7% (95% CI, 2.1 to 3.3). In univariable analysis, adjusted for chemotherapy, five of 12 variables were associated with LRR, including the 70-gene signature. In multivariable modeling, adjuvant endocrine therapy and to a lesser extent tumor size and grade remained significantly associated with LRR. CONCLUSION This exploratory analysis of the MINDACT trial estimated an 8-year low LRR rate of 3.2% after BCS. The 70-gene signature was not independently predictive of LRR perhaps because of the low number of events observed and currently cannot be used in clinical decision making regarding LRR. The overall low number of events does provide an opportunity to design trials toward de-escalation of local therapy.
Year:
2024
Background Superparamagnetic iron oxide nanoparticles (SPIO) have been used as a tracer for sentinel lymph node (SLN) localization in breast cancer, demonstrating comparable performance to the combination of radioisotope (RI) and blue dye (BD). Methods A systematic literature search and meta-analysis with subgroup and meta-regression analysis were undertaken to update the available evidence, assess technique evolution, and define knowledge gaps. Recommendations were made using the GRADE approach. Results In 20 comparative studies, the detection rate was 97.5 per cent for SPIO and 96.5 per cent for RI ± BD (risk ratio 1.006, 95 per cent c.i. 0.992 to 1.019; P = 0.376, high-certainty evidence). Neoadjuvant therapy, injection site, injection volume or nodal metastasis burden did not affect the detection rate, but injection over 24 h before surgery increased the detection rate on meta-regression. Concordance was 99.0 per cent and reverse concordance 97.1 per cent (rate difference 0.003, 95 per cent c.i. −0.009 to 0.015; P = 0.656, high-certainty evidence). Use of SPIO led to retrieval of slightly more SLNs (pooled mean 1.96 versus 1.89) with a higher nodal detection rate (94.1 versus 83.5 per cent; RR 1.098, 1.058 to 1.140; P < 0.001; low-certainty evidence). In meta-regression, injection over 24 h before surgery increased the SPIO nodal yield over that of RI ± BD. The skin-staining rate was 30.8 per cent (very low-certainty evidence), and possibly prevented with use of smaller doses and peritumoral injection. Conclusion The performance of SPIO is comparable to that of RI ± BD. Preoperative injection increases the detection rate and nodal yield, without affecting concordance. Whether skin staining and MRI artefacts are reduced by lower dose and peritumoral injection needs to be investigated.
Year:
2022
Collaborators (6)
Charles Edward Geyer Jr
Professor of Medicine in Division of Hematology/Medical Oncology
University of Pittsburgh
Nancy Lin
Associate Professor of Medicine
Dana-Farber Cancer Institute
Hope Rugo
Director, Women’s Cancer Program Division; Professor, Department of Medical Oncology & Therapeutics Research; Chief, Breast Medical Oncology
City Of Hope National Medical Center
Sara Hurvitz
Professor, Division Head
Washington University School of Medicine
Sandra M. Swain
Georgetown University Medical Center
Laura J. van 't Veer
University of California, San Francisco
Make your next move.
Prepare your application
Review drafts before you send them.