Jeanne Galaine

Treatment with T cells expressing chimeric antigen receptors (CAR) is a promising anticancer therapy. However, this approach has several limitations and has not yet been effectively applied to treat solid tumors. The study by Panowski and colleagues represents the first comparative analysis of multiple single chain fragment variable (scFv)-based anti-CD70 CAR T-cell clones for the development of a clinical product to treat renal cell carcinoma (RCC). Despite the risk of T-cell fratricide due to CD70 expression on T cells, CD70 CAR T cells were produced successfully thanks to the protective CD70 masking phenomenon. Two distinct classes of CAR T cells were identified with different memory phenotypes, activation statuses, and cytotoxic activity. CD70 CAR T cells presented high cytotoxic activity against RCC both in vitro in RCC cell lines and in vivo in patient-derived xenograft mouse models. The off-target effects expected on the lymphoid compartment were confirmed by tissue cross-reactivity staining and in a cynomolgus monkey preclinical model with CD3-CD70 bispecific antibody treatment. The efficacy and the toxicity profile of the lead CD70 CAR T-cell candidate instigated the researchers to proceed with upscaled clinical production. This article emphasizes the influence of the scFv of the CARs on their efficacy:toxicity balance. Ultimately, they successfully managed to develop a highly effective CAR T-cell candidate to treat a solid tumor by an allogeneic approach, thereby overcoming two major hurdles to broaden application of CAR T-cell therapy. See related article by Panowski et al., p. 2610