Nadine Mengis
Emmy Noether research group leader
Research Interests
Make your next move.
Prepare your application
Review drafts before you send them.
Explore related searches
Articles (21)
Year:
2026
Artificial upwelling (AU) is investigated as a marine carbon dioxide removal (CDR) method with a strong focus on its potential impact on Earth’s carbon cycle, in particular enhanced air-sea CO 2 flux. The overarching goal of marine CDR methods is to contribute to offsetting remaining CO 2 emissions as a means to stabilize global mean surface air temperature (SAT). However, AU also directly affects ocean heat uptake (OHU) through the upwelling of cold ocean interior water to the surface and the simultaneous backflow of warm surface water into the ocean interior. In this study, we challenge the carbon centered perception of AU. We simulate large-scale AU in an Earth system model of intermediate complexity between the years 2025 and 2100 with and without its direct impact on OHU under low, medium and high future CO 2 emission scenarios. Thus, we can quantify the individual contributions of AU-induced carbon and heat effects to changes in global mean SAT. We find the direct impact of AU on OHU to be key for a significant reduction in global mean SAT and the atmosphere’s CO 2 concentration under all simulated future CO 2 emission pathways. If AU directly impacts OHU, we can attribute only 17% under RCP 2.6 to 27% under RCP 8.5 of the reduction in global mean SAT (−0.17 to −0.27 °C) until the end of the century to the reduction in the atmosphere’s CO 2 inventory (−5.9 to −31.2 Pg C). Our findings lead us to challenge the classical view of AU as primarily a marine CDR method. Instead, we propose to consider AU as a method to enhance OHU and thereby reduce global mean SAT, with secondary effects on the carbon cycle that result in some CDR.
Year:
2025
Marine carbon dioxide removal (mCDR) implementations can potentially remove 1–15 Gt CO 2 yr −1 , which encompasses the minimum requirement removal of CDR in 2050 to limit warming below 2 °C by 2100. Despite their potential, mCDR represents only a tiny fraction of currently deployed CDR methods. Their implementations require not only a comprehensive understanding of the marine processes involved, but also a robust monitoring for their effectiveness and potential environmental impacts. In this work, we surveyed the mCDR scientific literature to identify measurable indicators for quantitative information across different ecosystems and methods used for monitoring the carbon removed and environmental side-effects, and explore the main common challenges. We followed the preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analysis protocol PRISMA: the search queries were established, and the literature search and criteria for inclusion/exclusion were transparently defined. Our results reveal the lack of a direct linkage from the mCDR-induced rates of chemical and biological changes to the amount of carbon removed from the atmosphere and the magnitude of associated environmental side-effects. The heterogeneity of marine biogeochemical and ecological processes in time and space, together with the propagation of biogeochemical signals in an open system, represent the most common challenge reported for the monitoring approaches. Our results show that we are in need of indicators that provide reliable quantification of CO 2 removal rates and information on environmental side-effects. Finally, based on our gap analysis, we provide monitoring recommendations, such as the use of common metrics and the baseline establishment. Currently, the lack of standardized indicators and monitoring procedures inhibits the verification, and hence, creates risks for further investment and prevents the entering of mCDRs in existing carbon certificate trading systems, hindering the long term growth of this sector.
Year:
2025
To meet global climate targets, carbon dioxide removal (CDR) techniques are essential alongside efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Among marine CDR (mCDR) approaches, the enhancement of the ocean’s role as a natural "blue carbon" sink, particularly through the cultivation of pelagic macroalgae, is gaining increasing attention for its potential to scale carbon sequestration.For these approaches to be viable and sustainable, they must undergo rigorous evaluation. This study assesses the potential of scaling up seaweed cultivation, considering environmental effectiveness, durability, and risks. It situates this approach within the broader context of other mCDR strategies, including ocean alkalinity enhancement, enhanced coastal weathering, and coastal blue carbon. In addition, the study explores the role of macroalgae in producing products for defossilisation, contributing to the decarbonisation of industries reliant on fossil-derived materials.In a future step, the Unified Assessment Framework (ASMASYS), a transdisciplinary tool for evaluating marine CDR options, will be applied to assess the feasibility, sustainability, and risks of pelagic macroalgae in the context of global carbon sequestration efforts. This framework integrates scientific, social, legal, and governance factors, emphasizing sustainability and social acceptability.This work provides an interim synthesis of pelagic macroalgae's potential for large-scale carbon sequestration and defossilisation products. It also lays the foundation for future research, policy recommendations, and governance frameworks necessary for integrating seaweed cultivation into global climate and defossilisation strategies.
Year:
2025
The complex nexus between climate and ocean governance is increasingly being acknowledged. Not only is there growing awareness of the risks posed to marine environments by climate change (deoxygenation, acidification, coral bleaching, etc.), there is also an increasing focus on the role of the ocean in mitigating adverse effects of climate change. Proposals for intervening into marine environments to help mitigate climate change (either by increasing ocean carbon sequestration or albedo properties, sometimes collectively termed ‘marine geoengineering’) have proliferated in recent years. All of these proposals are in the early stage of development, and they present many environmental, technological, political and societal unknowns that are yet to be comprehensively researched and assessed. It is essential to adopt a broad and transdisciplinary approach to assessing ocean interventions for climate mitigation given the inherently dynamic and interconnected nature of marine ecosystems, the potential for conflicts with other marine activities and marine protection, as well as concerns about the possible effects on social and cultural relationships with the ocean.GESAMP is a group of independent experts that provides advice to the UN system on scientific aspects of marine environmental protection. In 2015, GESAMP established Working Group 41 on ‘marine geoengineering’ under the lead of International Maritime Organization (IMO) and supported by The Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission of UNESCO (IOC-UNESCO) and World Meteorological Organization (WMO). In 2019, GESAMP WG41 published a report which undertook one of the first high-level assessments of ‘marine geoengineering’ interventions. The report highlighted that the assessment was not able to be fully comprehensive, and that there was a need to further “[f]oster the development of socio-economic, geopolitical and other relevant societal aspects of marine geoengineering assessments, including societally relevant metrics where possible, to ensure a holistic approach to subsequent assessment process(es)” (GESAMP 2019). Building upon this recommendation, the Terms of Reference for the second phase of GESAMP WG 41 that began in 2020 state that one key task of the expanded group is to: ‘Develop a framework to integrate inputs from natural sciences and societal disciplines into a holistic assessment of ocean interventions for climate change mitigation or other purposes consistent with the London Protocol’s definition of marine geoengineering, to be used by regulators, policy-makers, funders or anyone considering or permitting proposals’.WG 41 has correspondingly developed a transdisciplinary Ocean Intervention Assessment Framework (OIAF) that is designed to help a wide variety of potential users (i.e. state regulators, policy-makers, developers, funders and other stakeholders involved in assessing and permitting proposals) to holistically assess relevant ecological, scientific, institutional and societal issues that may arise in relation to ocean intervention proposals.This presentation/paper presents and discusses the GESAMP OIAF by: (1) outlining and reflecting upon the process by which it was developed; (2) providing an illustrative example of how it could be applied to a specific ocean intervention proposal, and (3) showing how the application of the framework can help all those involved in future research, assessment, development and management of ocean interventions to embody the ethos of responsible research and innovation.
Year:
2025
As the global temperature approaches an average of 1.5°C above preindustrial levels - the most ambitious limit set in the 2015 Paris climate agreement - researchers and policymakers are increasingly considering overshoot pathways that aim to mitigate the impacts of transgressing these guardrails. Such overshoot narratives warrant cautious consideration:Firstly, achieving net-zero goals is challenging as it is. But achieving large-scale net-negative CO2 emissions on a global scale to reverse a temperature or carbon budget transgression will be even more challenging, when considering context-specific feasibility and desirability constraints to the implementation of carbon dioxide removal (CDR) options (see e.g. Borchers et al., 2024). Secondly, if we would achieve global net-negative CO2 emissions, detecting a temperature overshoots amidst internal climate variability will pose a considerable challenge, that would considerably complicate the monitoring and accordingly the management of such anthropogenic interventions into the climate system.Thirdly, the financial, social, and governance frameworks required to incentivise, implement and sustain global net-negative CO2 emissions to manipulate the atmospheric CO2 concentration, similar to other forms of climate interventions, are likely unattainable. Fourth, even if these barriers were overcome, the resulting post-overshoot climate would very likely differ from one where temperature stabilisation is maintained without overshoot (see e.g., Schleussner et al., 2024), with potentially irreversible impacts on ecosystems and climate systems.Mitigation deterrence - reducing incentives for near-term emissions reductions - represents an considerable risk associated with CDR and overshoot narratives (Carton et al., 2023). It is therefore crucial to approach overshoot research and communication with care, prioritising immediate and effective mitigation strategies to minimise reliance on uncertain and potentially unfeasible overshoot pathways. Borchers, M., Förster, J., Thrän, D., Beck, S., Thoni, T., Korte, K., et al. (2024). A comprehensive assessment of carbon dioxide removal options for Germany. Earth's Future, 12, e2023EF003986. https://doi.org/10.1029/2023EF003986 Schleussner, CF., Ganti, G., Lejeune, Q. et al. Overconfidence in climate overshoot. Nature 634, 366–373 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-024-08020-9Carton, W., Hougaard, I.-M., Markusson, N., & Lund, J. F. (2023). Is carbon removal delaying emission reductions? WIREs Climate Change, 14(4), e826. https://doi.org/10.1002/wcc.82
Year:
2025
The objective of the Paris Agreement is to obtain commitments from signing parties to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions to levels consistent with a global warming well below 2 °C above pre-industrial levels and to pursue further efforts to limit it to 1.5 °C. To achieve such ambitious goals, countries should collectively aim to reach a global peak in GHG emissions as soon as possible and to steadily decrease their emissions after that, to ideally accomplish a climate neutral world by the middle of this century. However, it soon became clear that the efforts being committed by signing parties were not enough to achieve such ambitious goals. As a result, the world is currently on track to warming levels that will either temporarily or permanently exceed the agreed temperature targets. Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) can complement the phase-out of fossil fuels, supporting net emission reduction towards the achievement of net-zero and, in case of temperature overshoot, net-negative targets. To reach such goals, while limiting the severity of side-effects, a broad set of CDR options - a CDR portfolio - will be necessary.The RESCUE project aims to develop realistic scenarios that incorporate a mix of large-scale implementations of technology- and ecosystem-based CDR. These scenarios are based on the current state-of-the-art knowledge regarding various aspects, including the limits and constraints of CDR on both land and ocean. The actual effectiveness of these CDR portfolios depends on a series of mechanisms and feedback loops linked to a changing climate.Currently, the only tools that allow us to understand, assess, and quantify the processes that might affect the effectiveness of large-scale CDR interventions are Earth System Models (ESMs). However, even state-of-the-art ESMs are not yet equipped to represent the variety of CDR approaches being proposed. The RESCUE project is developing these representations in five European ESMs. The rationale behind these developments is to advance beyond the approach used in CMIP6, where negative emissions were prescribed from socioeconomic models as part of a given scenario. Inline with the CMIP7 emissions-driven experimental design focus, CDR interventions in RESCUE are provided to the ESMs as activities (e.g., area and carbon capture and storage efficiency of bioenergy plantations or alkalinity additions to the ocean) with the potential to alter net land and ocean CO2 fluxes. However, the ESM itself quantifies the actual effectiveness, taking into account known climate interactions and feedbacks. Here, we describe the overall design of these CDR representations, necessary assumptions and future directions for their improvement.
Year:
2025
Achieving global temperature stabilisation requires net-zero CO₂ emissions, a goal widely recognised within the scientific community. However, a critical and contested question remains: will the Earth's climate continue to warm due to thermal and biogeochemical inertia even after emissions cease? This phenomenon, known as Zero Emissions Commitment (ZEC), has been estimated to likely be 0.0 ºC with a multi-model spread of 0.3°C. Considering its magnitude, ZEC may represent a significant fraction of the remaining warming before the 1.5°C threshold is reached.In an attempt to constrain uncertainties in ZEC estimates, this study presents findings from a large ensemble of simulations conducted using the University of Victoria Earth System Climate Model (UVic ESCM v2.10). The ensemble design systematically varies model parameters within observationally constrained ranges, targeting processes identified as having the largest potential influence on ZEC (Palazzo-Corner et al., 2023). These parameters include carbon cycle feedbacks, ocean heat uptake, and CO2 fertilisation effects, which are represented with appropriate and acceptable levels of complexity within the UVic ESCM.In line with the CMIP7 emissions-driven experimental design focus, we employ the esm-flat10-zec as well as esm-flat20-zec, which uses a constant emission rate of 10 PgC/yr and 20 PgC/yr, respectively (Sanderson et al., 2024), with varying cumulative emission budgets. This approach allows for the exploration of ZEC parameter uncertainty under varying emission rates and carbon budgets, increasing our process-based understanding of the metric. ReferencesSanderson, B. M. et al. The need for carbon-emissions-driven climate projections in CMIP7. Geoscientific Model Development 17, 8141–8172 (2024).Palazzo Corner, S. et al. The Zero Emissions Commitment and climate stabilization. Frontiers in Science 1, 1170744 (2023).
Year:
2025
Assessing Earth system feedbacks arising from carbon dioxide removal (CDR) requires developing and simulating pairs of scenarios - a mitigation scenario with deployment of CDR and a corresponding no-CDR baseline. Both scenarios respect a specific long-term constraint on a carbon emission budget (i.e. emission reductions are pursued at the same level of ambition), but the latter describes a world where no CDR is deployed, such that net carbon emissions are larger and a given temperature threshold is missed. While over the past years a rich literature on deep mitigation scenarios with CDR has been emerging, the need for such no-CDR baselines has never been articulated explicitly. In idealized Earth system model (ESM) simulations of CDR, a no-CDR baseline is easy to imagine and implement, since socio-economic constraints are typically not taken into account. However, the deployment of CDR in deep mitigation scenarios, created by integrated assessment models (IAMs), is embedded in a consistent socio-economic description of plausible futures, and disallowing CDR may change many aspects of such scenarios, for example, the energy-system and land-use. Particularly, when moving towards an “activity-driven” representation of CDR in ESMs, where the activity that leads to a drawdown of CO2 is explicitly modelled (rather than prescribed by using removal fluxes from the IAM simulation), the creation of no-CDR baselines comes with challenges. Here, we conceptualize how carbon cycle and biophysical feedbacks of CDR deployment can be determined from scenario simulations and corresponding no-CDR baselines. We show that different options exist for the creation of no-CDR baselines, which offer different insights and have their specific advantages and limitations. We argue that for certain applications (e.g., the determination of regional biophysical feedbacks) the use of idealized no-CDR baselines is unavoidable to some extent, implying that we have to accept some degree of socio-economic inconsistency in no-CDR baselines.
Year:
2025
Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) encompasses a wide range of anthropogenic activities to remove CO2 from the atmosphere to reduce its climate warming effect. The implementation of CDR technologies is necessary to achieve global climate-temperature goals. Commonly, negative emissions effects on the climate and carbon cycle have been thought to be nearly equal but opposite to those of positive emissions. This assumption was challenged recently, with results showing an asymmetric response of the Earth system to positive and negative emissions over a 1000-year timescale (Zickfeld et al. 2021). Positive emissions showed a more potent effect at increasing atmospheric CO2 concentration than negative emissions at reducing it. Yet, positive emissions had a less potent effect at increasing atmospheric temperature than negative emissions at decreasing it. Here we aim to re-evaluate the asymmetric climate-carbon response of the Earth system to negative emissions in a shorter-immediate timescale using an emissions-driven approach. Starting from a preindustrial spin-up the University of Victoria Earth system climate model (version 2.10) was forced with 10 PgC/yr emitted to the atmosphere until the cumulative carbon emission budget reached 1000 PgC (esmflat-10-1000PgC). Thereafter, pulses of positive and negative CO2 emissions ranging from ±50 to ±750 PgC were emitted or removed instantly. To assess the transient climate response to cumulative negative CO2 emissions a -10 PgC/yr was carried. Finally, a zero emission simulation from pre-industrial served as a control. Our results show agreement with the temperature and carbon asymmetry shown in previous studies. However, we only observed relative large differences with regards to atmospheric temperature and carbon redistribution in the first 40 years of simulations. Later responses (>50 years) show much small differences between the mirrored atmospheric CO2 concentrations and temperatures to negative and positive emissions. The transient climate response to cumulative CO2 emissions and cumulative CO2 removal was found to be 1.81 and -1.79 K/EgC, respectively. These findings suggest that, while temperature asymmetry may remain undetectable in the first century of negative emissions deployment, carbon cycle dynamics could deviate significantly from symmetric assumptions. This highlights the importance of accounting for asymmetric carbon redistribution when designing negative emission strategies. References:Zickfeld, K., Azevedo, D., Mathesius, S. et al. Asymmetry in the climate–carbon cycle response to positive and negative CO2 emissions. Nat. Clim. Chang. 11, 613–617 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41558-021-01061-2
Year:
2025
Year:
2025
Year:
2025
Year:
2025
Year:
2025
Year:
2024
Year:
2024
Year:
2024
Year:
2024
Year:
2024
Year:
2023
Year:
2023
Collaborators (38)
Hanna Lee
Associate Professor
Norwegian University of Science and Technology
Shraddha Gupta
Scientist for Model Development and Testing
Alfred Wegener Institute Helmholtz Centre for Polar and Marine Research
Daniela Thrän
Prof.
Helmholtz-Zentrum für Umweltforschung UFZ
Leon Merfort
Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research
Laurent Bopp
Institut Pierre-Simon Laplace
Miranda Boettcher
Utrecht University
Raffaele Bernardello
Senior Researcher
Barcelona Supercomputing Center
Hongmei Li
Max Planck Institute for Meteorology
Christian Baatz
Juniorprofessor
Kiel University
Julia Pongratz
-
Ivy Frenger
Research Scientist
GEOMAR Helmholtz-Zentrum für Ozeanforschung Kiel
Norman Julius Steinert
Senior Researcher
CICERO Center for International Climate Research
Zebedee Nicholls
Lecturer in Climate Modelling
University of Melbourne
Jonathan Buzan
Senior Scientist
Vrije Universiteit Brussel
Clare Heyward
UiT The Arctic University of Norway
Benjamin Sanderson
CICERO Center for International Climate Research
Wolfgang Bach
Professor
University of Bremen
Victor Brovkin
Max Planck Institute for Meteorology
David Wårlind
Lund University
Roland Séférian
-
Timothée Bourgeois
Senior researcher
NORCE Norwegian Research Centre
Sarah Sparrow
Associate Professor in Environmental Impact
University of Oxford
Gregor Rehder
Vice Head
Leibniz Institute for Baltic Sea Research
Nils Moosdorf
Professor for Coastal Hydrogeology
Kiel University
Mar Fernández-Méndez
Professor for Marine Algal Ecology and Applications
Alfred-Wegener-Institut für Polar und Meeresforschung
Jens Terhaar
University of Bern
Paul Miller
Senior Lecturer
Lund University
F. Joos
University of Bern
Tatiana Ilyina
Director
Max Planck Institute for Marine Microbiology
Jerry Tjiputra
NORCE Norwegian Research Centre
Judith Hauck
Helmholtz Young Investigator Group Leader
Alfred Wegener Institute Helmholtz Centre for Polar and Marine Research
Abigail Swann
Professor
University of Washington
Charles Koven
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Donghyun Lee
Research associate
Imperial College London
Katsumasa Tanaka
Team Leader / Principal Investigator
Laboratoire des Sciences du Climat et de l'Environnement
Christopher Smith
Vrije Universiteit Brussel
Andrew H. MacDougall
St. Francis Xavier University
Chris Jones
Professor
University of Bristol
Make your next move.
Prepare your application
Review drafts before you send them.