Colin Macarthur
Senior Scientist
Research Interests
Make your next move.
Prepare your application
Review drafts before you send them.
Explore related searches
Articles (9)
Year:
2026
Introduction Several systematic and scoping reviews have focused on the impact of patient and public involvement (PPI) in child health research. The aim of this research was to examine the data sources and analytic approaches used by researchers to evaluate the impact of PPI in child health research. Methods A comprehensive literature search identified published reviews focused on PPI impact in child health research. Titles, abstracts, and full texts were screened to determine eligibility. Individual studies from eligible reviews created the sampling frame, from which 100 individual studies were randomly selected. Information was extracted on primary study characteristics, type of PPI, data sources and analytic approaches used to evaluate PPI impact, and reported PPI impact. Frequency distributions were used to summarise the findings. Results The initial search yielded 5868 citations. After screening, 15 reviews (comprising 406 individual studies, of which 303 were unique) met inclusion criteria. Among the 100 randomly selected individual studies, PPI was reported across all phases of the research process including priority setting (30/100), input on study materials (50/100), and dissemination of study findings (52/100). The method of PPI was most commonly focus groups (29/100) or advisory committees (27/100). Of the 100 studies selected, 67/100 reported impact on the research process, 69/100 reported impact on patients and families, and 32/100 studies reported impact on researchers. Regarding the data sources used to evaluate PPI impact, 69/100 studies reviewed primary study field notes along with researcher observations and reflections, while 31/100 studies conducted independent, specific, focus groups and/or interviews and/or surveys to gather data. Regarding the analytic approaches used to evaluate PPI impact, formal qualitative and/or quantitative analyses of the data occurred in only 25/100 studies. Only 2/100 studies used a formal PPI reporting guideline. Conclusion Only 31/100 studies collected specific, independent data on the impact of PPI in child health research, and only 25/100 studies applied formal analyses. Robust evaluation of PPI impact in child health research is essential for a strong PPI evidence base. Patient or Public Contribution A patient partner (co‐author, FB) was a member of the research team from study inception, and contributed to the development of the study protocol, including refining the research question, input on study design, selection of relevant outcomes, interpretation of findings, writing the manuscript, and developing dissemination plans.
Year:
2026
Year:
2025
Background/Objectives: Patient and public involvement (PPI) in the design, conduct, and dissemination of pragmatic trials may make trial results more relevant and meaningful. The nature of PPI in paediatric pragmatic trials has been poorly characterized in the literature. This study examined the prevalence and nature of PPI in paediatric pragmatic trials and lessons learned from researchers’ experiences. Methods: For this mixed methods study, we conducted an online survey and semi-structured interviews with corresponding authors of published paediatric pragmatic trials, identified using an online search filter in MEDLINE. Descriptive statistics and qualitative thematic analysis were used to analyse the data. Results: PPI was reported by 71/127 (56%) survey respondents. Reported impacts of PPI in the survey included the following: more feasible interventions (71%), higher-quality research (57%), improved recruitment and retention (57%), and increased applicability of research findings (57%). Both survey and interview participants identified that insufficient resources, time, and training for relationship development were challenges to PPI in paediatric trials. Three themes were identified from the semi-structured interview data (recruitment and engagement, sustaining PPI relationships, and PPI value added). Conclusions: PPI aligns with the purpose and intended impact of pragmatic trials, and paediatric researchers perceive that PPI leads to increased research relevance, quality, and dissemination. There is, however, a need for institutional and funding bodies to invest in PPI partnership, including offering support for researchers and providing opportunities for children, youth, and parents as PPI partners.
Year:
2025
Year:
2025
Year:
2024
BACKGROUND Youth and families play an indispensable role in health research, given their unique lived experiences and expertise. Aligning research with patients’ needs, values, and preferences can significantly enhance its relevance and impact; however, recent research has highlighted various challenges and risks associated with youth and family engagement in health research. These challenges encompass the perils of tokenism, power imbalances and dynamics, questioning the motives behind engagement, and limited accessibility to patient-friendly training for patient partners, as well as inadequate training on patient engagement for researchers and the absence of equitable engagement tools. To address these risks and challenges, different patient engagement models, theories, frameworks, and guiding principles have been developed and adopted; to date, however, their transferability to youth- and family-specific engagement in research has been limited. OBJECTIVE The objectives of this project are (1) to determine the extent of the literature on the application of patient engagement models, theories, frameworks, and guiding principles in the context of youth-specific research; and (2) to determine how meaningful the key components and constructs of these models, theories, frameworks, and guiding principles are to youth and their family members. METHODS This project will use an integrated knowledge translation approach and consists of 2 phases: (1) a scoping review to identify patient engagement models, theories, frameworks and guiding principles in youth research; and (2) a qualitative descriptive study using one-on-one semistructured interviews with youth and family members to understand their conceptualization of meaningful engagement in health research. For phase 1, the following databases were searched: Medline, CINAHL, EMBASE, PsycINFO, and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials. Literature from 2013 to August 28, 2024, was captured. Primary studies using a patient engagement in research model, theory, or framework, or guiding principles, in youth will be included. The risk of bias of included studies will not be assessed. Extracted data will be quantitatively summarized using numerical counts and qualitatively using content analysis. For phase 2, we will recruit 9 to 17 youth and 9 to 17 family members. Transcripts will be analyzed using an inductive approach outlined by Braun and Clarke. RESULTS The project has received funding from the Canadian Institutes of Health Research. A 9-member integrated knowledge translation panel consisting of 6 youth and 3 family members has been established. CONCLUSIONS The findings from this study will identify what is currently known about the application of patient engagement models, theories, frameworks, and guiding principles in youth-specific research and the important components of these models, theories, frameworks, and guiding principles from the perspective of youth and their families. These findings will be instrumental to developing a youth- and family-specific engagement in research framework called the UNITE framework and subsequently, a validated measure. INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT PRR1-10.2196/65733
Year:
2024
Year:
2023
Year:
2023
Collaborators (15)
Tieghan Killackey
Assistant Professor
University of Toronto
F Virginia Wright
Professor (Status)
University of Toronto
Gina Dimitropoulos
University of Calgary
Monica Taljaard
Scientist
Ottawa Hospital Research Institute
Dean Fergusson
Full Professor
University of Ottawa
Charles Weijer
Professor
Western University
Elaine Biddiss
-
Niles Chavon
Assistant Professor
University of Toronto
Linda Rothman
Associate Professor
Ryerson University
Christine Cassidy
Assistant Professor
Dalhousie University
Andrea Cross
Assistant Professor
McMaster University
Scott Hadland
Associate Professor
Harvard University
Beth K. Potter
Professor
University of Ottawa
Monika Kastner
Associate Professor
University of Toronto
Stuart Nicholls
Assistant Professor
University of Ottawa
Make your next move.
Prepare your application
Review drafts before you send them.